Concert Review

David Massengill, Guthrie Center, June 24, 2000
By Seth Rogovoy

(GREAT BARRINGTON, Mass., June 25, 2000)
CONCERT REVIEW David Massengill, Guthrie Center, June 24, 2000 By Seth Rogovoy David Massengill threw out the conventional singer-songwriters playbook - the one full of navel-gazing confessions of romantic heartache -- and instead took an intimate audience at the Guthrie Center on Saturday night on an old-fashioned, oral-folk journey to his hometown of Bristol, Tennessee. In stories, readings and songs, Massengill brought to life the town, the times, and the characters who inhabited the town over the last 150 years.

Apparently spurred on to the project by the recent decline and death of his father, Massengill delved into the corners and byways of Bristol, shining a particularly bright light on his own family's history and legacy. The result is a kind of Faulkneresque body of work, one that over the course of 90 minutes built an entire world for his listeners.

It was an utterly uncommercial and ultimately winning effort by Massengill, who has called New York City home for many years, but who hasn't lost his substantial Southern grace and charm.

Accompanying himself alternately on strap-on dulcimer and acoustic guitar, Massengill sang original ballads based on people and incidents from Bristol's past.

We met Frank Goodpasture, who moved in across the street from Massengill's father when he was just a little boy. Frank had a pony, and because of that he was deemed a valued playmate by pere Massengill. But much to the chagrin of his peers, pony rides on Frank's Shetland were few and far between.

In "Culture Hurts," we met Mr. Cataldo, the small-town music-and-manners teacher who believed that whatever couldn't be taught to his young charges, among whom was Massengill's father, could be beaten into them.

Another song recounted a hike - now legendary in Bristol - taken by Massengill's father and two fellow Eagle Scout friends, in which the young men got lost overnight in the woods and had the whole town in a panic. We also heard songs about cousins and brothers, including a poignant tune about two orphan brothers sent out west on an orphan train, from where they were forever separated after being adopted by different families. In "Girl From Nebraska," we heard the story of how Massengill's parents got hitched, and "Mama at the Pool Hall" recounted the humorous story of how Massengill's very proper grandmother wound up in that unsavory place instead of the town bank.

"Mrs. Cradle" was one of the few tunes that in some way directly involved Massengill himself. The town doctor's wife, she was the object of the four-year-old David's affection who one day consented to take him with her on her shopping rounds and show him off as her boyfriend. "My Home Must Be a Special Place" was another song from the point of view of a young David Massengill, this one tenderly evoking the belief of a young boy that he is the center of the universe, that the moon and the stars literally move along with his comings and goings.

Taken individually, any of several of these tunes treaded perilously close to mawkishness. But with his resonant, conversational baritone, his gentle, evocative accompaniment, and readings from primary documents - letters and essays by his forebears - Massengill succeeded in creating a dramatic setting in which these sentimental tales could be placed without relying on excess sentimentality.

"They're not going to change the world," Massengill prefaced modestly about his new body of songs. Indeed, in this day, it will be a miracle if Massengill can convince anyone to even record and distribute such boldly old-fashioned folk ballads. The best he can hope for is to emphasize the oral history and educational aspect of his new work and perhaps get some grant money to support some kind of non-profit-backed recording or theatrical presentation of this fine new literary work.

[This column originally appeared in the Berkshire Eagle on June 28, 2000. Copyright Seth Rogovoy 2000. All rights reserved.]



Search by


Seth Rogovoy
rogovoy@berkshire.net
music news, interviews, reviews, et al.


Next Article || Previous Article || Back